There is an annual competition known as CSBG DC/Marvel Character Tournament!.
In simple words, it is a way of eliminating your least favorite movie. You can check the table below to see the complete list of elimination and everything. It was a really tough competition. Till 3000 votes, it was a tie. However when total of 3104 votes were casted, Captain America: The Winter Soldier emerged victorious by 64 votes. Yes, just 64 votes.
As you can see from the table below, the movies are clubbed in pairs, and the least favorite is eliminated.
Yes, everyone is kind of shocked at the result. The only explanation possible is “The Dark Knight” was very far from the comics. Well, still we all are shocked to see the result.